emperor: (Default)
Add MemoryShare This Entry
posted by [personal profile] emperor at 04:25pm on 21/07/2006 under
Need week I need to design a scientific poster to take to ISVEE. I want to have a reasonably good end result, hopefully without too much pain. My computer runs Macos X, although I also have access to solaris and linux boxes (well, I could probably get my hands on a Windows box if I really had to).

I've occasionally had to interact with powerpoint, and hated it. I have reasonable LaTeX skills, but am not, for example, up to writing my own class files. I'm not sure how best to approach getting this poster done (assume I have most of the graphs &c I want to use already sorted out).

[Poll #774885]

Any further comments (e.g. sugestions of specific tools / LaTeX packages / Powerpoint macros) gratefully received...
There are 13 comments on this entry. (Reply.)
 
posted by [identity profile] gnimmel.livejournal.com at 03:41pm on 21/07/2006
I've done a couple of posters in LaTeX: there are quite a lot of template files out there (googling for 'Latex poster style file' should get you them). It's OK provided you don't want to do anything particularly fancy -- eg. there didn't appear to be any way of putting in a background image which was either elegant or didn't produce ugly results. I'd recommend it if you're doing a poster with lots of equations on (although arguably posters shouldn't have lots of equations on!) or you just want writing and figures.

NB. I'd check what format the printers will take, particularly before choosing a 'none of the above' option -- in my case they'd only take powerpoint or PDF. Previously I found this out rather late and converting A0 postscript to acceptable A0 PDF turned out to take longer than I thought -- the same may apply to other formats.
 
posted by [identity profile] purplepiano.livejournal.com at 04:09pm on 21/07/2006
Yeah. I've never found the ideal solution for posters. Indeed for presentations in general. In powerpoint and suchlike equations are crap, and in LaTeX visual layout is crap. There are supposed to be tools which let you embed LaTeX in powerpoint, but I've never investigated them as they were either commercial or I had the wrong version of powerpoint. Every time I do a presentation I say "next time I'll try to find a nice LaTeX class file", but when it comes round to it I can never be arsed.

(in other words, I'm of no help!)
 
What you're doing is desktop publishing, in the strict sense of the word, so a slide-design (Powerpoint) or a book-typesetting (TeX) package is not what you want.

I think this is an opportunity to find a place where you can use the licensed copy of InDesign, QuarkXpress or Illustrator that I'm sure the university has access to, or to use Scribus or maybe even Inkscape from the free-software world (I don't know how Inkscape is at handling formatted text boxes); or, I suspect, to use Word.

http://www.plokta.com/plokta/issue26/issue26.pdf is done in Word, which gives some idea of what's possible ... if the large page sizes are an issue you could presumably design in 4-point type on A4, I know that the large-format plotter we had at work needed to be fed with A4-size images with ridiculously small text and plotted them on A0 scaled up by a factor four in each direction.

I've had a play with oowriter, which I cannot recommend for this because it seems to do lots of positioning off the top of its head without paying the slightest attention to where I've dragged the positioning and sizing bars of the frames I've been inserting.
 
posted by [identity profile] 3c66b.livejournal.com at 04:26pm on 21/07/2006
People I know claim that Adobe Illustrator is the bees' knees. At current workplace we are forced to use Corel Draw, which is actually not that bad once you get used to its strange UI. Both are considerably better than Powerpoint for posters, though Powerpoint is usable at a pinch. LaTeX posters are too much work to make pretty: I wouldn't consider using LaTeX for anything that I wanted to be colourful and eye-catching. Obviously Illustrator and Corel Draw are large expensive non-free packages and only worth considering if your dept. has them.
 
posted by [identity profile] meirion.livejournal.com at 05:09pm on 21/07/2006
if you want the LaTeX file i used to create posters when i still thought i had any hopes of making it as an academic, do shout. but if you don't shout this evening, it'll be monday before i can realistically do anything, as i shall be in oxford from early tomorrow morning until then.

-m-
emperor: (Default)
posted by [personal profile] emperor at 09:25pm on 21/07/2006
If you could mail it to me, that would be a great help. Thanks!
 
posted by [identity profile] hmw26.livejournal.com at 05:39pm on 21/07/2006
I've made posters in LaTeX and in Inkscape. I definitely recommend the latter. If you're running OS X though, you could make your poster in either Keynote or OmniGraffle. The nicest posters at the conferences I go to always seem to be done in either Keynote or OmniGraffle.
toothycat: (sunkitten)
posted by [personal profile] toothycat at 05:52pm on 21/07/2006
Were it up to me, I'd use a graphics program - Paintshop Pro is what my own computer runs, but Illustrator is also a lovely piece of kit if you have access to it and are on reasonable terms with it.
That said, the one poster I (co-)produced was done as a 1m^2 Powerpoint slide ^^;;
 
posted by [identity profile] caliston.livejournal.com at 05:54pm on 21/07/2006
Our group tends to use Illustrator for posters, though it had a fairly uninituitive interface that left me screaming at it.

Personally I'd use RISC OS Draw (or Artworks if I owned a copy), but then I'm like that...
 
posted by [identity profile] mostlyacat.livejournal.com at 12:21pm on 24/07/2006
Yay for RISC OS !Draw. I used to use that when I had an Acorn A3000 years ago.
 
posted by [identity profile] arnhem.livejournal.com at 10:23pm on 21/07/2006
If you go down the LaTeX route, you may find bits of the CUED help pages useful.

Top tip: if you use anything that allows you to embed postscript graphics, run the original postscript files through psclean (basically anything that calls ghostscript with the pswrite driver) before embedding them. If there's anything worse than finding that a bit of rogue matlab output has changed the global transformation matrix half way through a document, it's finding it when that document is being printed on an A0 printer at #25 a sheet ...
 
posted by [identity profile] tienelle.livejournal.com at 08:27pm on 23/07/2006
You should use a dedicated DTP program. Scribus is slightly insane, but free. I don't know about professional DTP programs; they're probably better than Scribus.
 
posted by [identity profile] mostlyacat.livejournal.com at 12:30pm on 24/07/2006
I guess it depends on your level aversion to piracy. If you find you have a parrot on your shoulder then get a big commercial graphics/DTP package like Illustrator. MS Visio is quite good for diagrammey things too. There might be cheap alternatives out there possibly. Otherwise Word is reasonable for this sort of thing ish and probably you won't need to grow a wooden leg or hook hand. I wouldn't use powerpoint it is too chunky and imprecise for this.

Years and years ago I had to do some diagrams or something at a company and there was no graphics software and Word was shite then so I used Excel - set the cell size to be small and use that as a grid. I drew a diagram representing beer being bottled at Becks brewery in Bremen yay.

October

SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
      1
 
2
 
3
 
4
 
5
 
6
 
7
 
8
 
9
 
10
 
11
 
12
 
13
 
14
 
15
 
16
 
17
 
18
 
19
 
20
 
21
 
22
 
23
 
24
 
25
26
 
27
 
28
 
29
 
30
 
31